The Guilty Are Afraid
WHAT WAS INEC CHAIRMAN, PROFESSOR JOASH AMUPITAN, RUNNING AWAY FROM IN LONDON?
By
Nze David N. Ugwu
There are moments when the conduct of public officials communicates more than their carefully prepared speeches. Sometimes, silence speaks louder than words. Sometimes, a refusal to answer a simple question raises more troubling questions than the question itself. And sometimes, the manner in which a public official responds to criticism reveals the depth of the crisis of confidence surrounding the institution he represents.
The recent encounter between the Chairman of the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC), Professor Joash Amupitan, and a group of protesting Nigerians outside Chatham House in London provides one of such moments.
The video circulating on social media is disturbing, not necessarily because of the protesters’ conduct, but because of what the encounter represents for the future of Nigeria’s democracy.
The protesters, apparently dissatisfied with the credibility of INEC and concerned about preparations for the 2027 general elections, surrounded the vehicle conveying the INEC Chairman and demanded that he come out and address their concerns. They wanted answers about his preparedness to conduct free, fair and credible elections in 2027. They questioned the integrity of the electoral process and demanded accountability from the man constitutionally entrusted with protecting the sanctity of the ballot.
But the INEC Chairman remained inside his vehicle. He neither came out to engage the protesters nor made any audible attempt to address their concerns.
The question Nigerians should be asking is simple: What was the INEC Chairman afraid of?
Was it a question of not knowing what to say? Was he uncomfortable with the questions being raised? Was he afraid of being confronted with issues he could not satisfactorily explain? Or was it simply a security decision based on the advice of his protection team?
We may never know what was going through his mind at that moment. It would be unfair to conclude, without evidence, that his refusal to come out was an admission of guilt. However, public officials must understand that their actions are often interpreted against the background of public confidence, institutional credibility and the responsibilities of their offices.
And that is precisely where the problem lies.
Professor Amupitan was not an ordinary Nigerian caught in an uncomfortable public confrontation. He is the Chairman of Nigeria’s electoral umpire, an institution whose credibility will determine whether millions of Nigerians accept the outcome of the 2027 elections.
He was in London, not Lagos, Kano or Abuja. He was attending an international engagement at one of the world’s prominent policy institutions, where he had the opportunity to explain Nigeria’s democratic trajectory and the preparations being made for the next general elections.
One would have expected the Chairman of an independent electoral commission to be comfortable explaining his institution’s preparedness, particularly when confronted with questions about its neutrality and credibility.
After all, what exactly is the responsibility of an electoral umpire if not to answer questions about the integrity of the electoral process?
The protesters were not asking him to announce election results. They were demanding explanations about the credibility of the institution he heads. If the allegations were unfounded, he had an opportunity to say so. If there were genuine problems, he had an opportunity to explain what INEC was doing to address them.
Leadership is not tested when everybody agrees with you. It is tested when people disagree with you, question your decisions and challenge your credibility.
A leader who can only address friendly audiences but cannot engage hostile questions is yet to demonstrate the full meaning of leadership.
To be fair, the protesters’ use of insults and aggressive language was unnecessary. No public official should be subjected to personal abuse or intimidation. Peaceful protest is a democratic right, but that right must be exercised responsibly. Equally, the Chairman was entitled to reasonable security precautions. Nobody should demand that a public official expose himself to physical danger merely to prove his courage.
However, there is a difference between protecting one’s personal safety and avoiding public accountability.
The distinction matters.
THE CRISIS OF CONFIDENCE
The London confrontation did not happen in a vacuum. It occurred against the background of growing public suspicion about the independence and credibility of INEC ahead of the 2027 elections.
The 2023 general elections left serious questions about the electoral process, particularly the failure to deliver on public expectations regarding the electronic transmission and real-time viewing of polling-unit results.
The controversies surrounding the presidential election damaged public confidence in the commission. Indeed, Professor Amupitan himself acknowledged during his Chatham House engagement that the 2023 election had created a significant trust deficit from which INEC had not fully recovered.
That admission is important.
An electoral commission cannot afford to conduct elections without the confidence of the people. Elections are not merely about counting votes and declaring winners. They are about convincing citizens that their votes count, that the rules apply equally to all contestants and that the electoral umpire has no preferred candidate.
Unfortunately, the controversy surrounding the preliminary voters’ register has introduced another dimension to the credibility challenge.
Questions have been raised about suspected artificial intelligence-generated photographs, duplicate registrations, questionable voter details and other alleged irregularities. INEC has acknowledged problems with some registration records and announced measures to address them, including the removal of invalid entries and investigations into suspected misconduct by registration officials.
These allegations have not established that the Chairman personally manipulated the register or that INEC has deliberately compromised the 2027 elections. Nevertheless, they raise legitimate questions that deserve transparent answers.
The responsibility of INEC is not to dismiss every criticism as politically motivated. Its responsibility is to investigate complaints, publish verifiable information and demonstrate that its processes are beyond partisan manipulation.
An electoral commission should never ask citizens to trust it blindly. It must earn that trust through transparency, consistency, fairness and demonstrable independence.
THE APC CAP: A DISTURBING SYMBOL OF PARTISANSHIP
Perhaps one of the most disturbing aspects of the video, as described by observers, is the appearance of an individual identified as an INEC staff member wearing a cap bearing the insignia of the All Progressives Congress (APC).
If the individual is indeed an INEC employee, the incident raises serious questions about the understanding of institutional neutrality within the commission.
How can an official of an electoral regulatory agency openly identify with a political party through partisan clothing while representing an institution constitutionally required to conduct elections impartially?
Is this the new understanding of neutrality within INEC?
Would the same employee feel comfortable wearing a cap bearing the insignia of the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP), Labour Party or African Democratic Congress (ADC) while performing official duties? Would such conduct be acceptable if the party involved were in opposition?
These are not trivial questions.
INEC is not an extension of the APC, PDP or any other political organization. It is a constitutional institution established to regulate the electoral process and provide a level playing field for all political parties and candidates.
Its officials must understand that neutrality is not merely an internal administrative requirement. It is the foundation upon which public confidence in the electoral process rests.
Even where an individual employee has personal political preferences, those preferences must never be allowed to compromise the appearance or reality of impartiality while discharging official responsibilities.
In public institutions, perception matters. An electoral official does not need to manipulate a ballot paper before creating suspicion about his neutrality. Sometimes, seemingly insignificant conduct can undermine confidence in the entire institution.
The APC cap, if the identity and employment status of the individual are confirmed, represents a serious public relations and institutional management failure.
INEC should investigate the matter and explain whether the individual was indeed its employee, the circumstances under which he was wearing the party insignia and whether the conduct violates its rules and code of ethics.
Silence will only create room for further speculation.
THE ELECTORAL UMPIRE MUST NOT BE SEEN AS A PLAYER
There is a fundamental principle in every credible sporting competition: the referee must never be seen as a player.
The moment the referee begins to display sympathy for one team, the integrity of the competition becomes questionable, regardless of whether the referee actually influences the outcome.
The same principle applies to electoral administration.
INEC is the referee in Nigeria’s democratic competition. Political parties are the contestants, candidates are the competitors, and the Nigerian electorate owns the game.
The electoral umpire must therefore maintain sufficient distance from every political party to inspire confidence among all participants.
It is not enough for the Chairman to repeatedly declare that his loyalty is to the Constitution and the Electoral Act. Those declarations must be supported by conduct that leaves no reasonable doubt about his independence.
This is particularly important in a country where electoral outcomes are frequently contested, political institutions are deeply distrusted and accusations of manipulation have become almost routine.
The Chairman must appreciate that the burden of demonstrating neutrality is considerably heavier on him than on ordinary citizens.
He must avoid situations that create unnecessary suspicion, even when he believes such suspicions are politically motivated.
The credibility of INEC cannot depend exclusively on the personal assurances of its Chairman. It must be reflected in the conduct of its commissioners, directors, resident electoral commissioners, returning officers and other employees across the country.
An institution cannot be neutral at the top and partisan at the bottom.
2027 IS TOO IMPORTANT TO BE LEFT TO PROMISES
Nigeria is approaching another critical electoral cycle. The 2027 general elections will take place against the background of economic hardship, political dissatisfaction, growing insecurity and declining public confidence in democratic institutions.
For millions of Nigerians, the ballot box remains one of the few constitutional instruments through which they can peacefully express their dissatisfaction with government and demand political change.
If citizens begin to believe that their votes will not count, the consequences could be dangerous.
Democracy survives not merely because elections are conducted periodically, but because citizens believe that elections provide a credible opportunity to choose their leaders.
Once that belief disappears, political apathy grows, electoral participation declines and frustration with democratic governance intensifies.
This is why the INEC Chairman must understand that his responsibility goes beyond organizing an election. He must protect the confidence of Nigerians in the electoral process.
He must provide clear answers to questions about electronic transmission of results, the integrity of the voters’ register, the independence of electoral officials, the deployment of technology and the safeguards against manipulation.
He must also demonstrate that no political party, including the ruling party, enjoys preferential treatment from the commission.
The Chairman should be more concerned about the credibility of the 2027 elections than about the criticism directed at his person.
He should welcome scrutiny, encourage independent monitoring and establish mechanisms through which citizens can report suspected irregularities without fear or intimidation.
The commission should also publish regular progress reports on its preparations for the elections, including the measures being taken to prevent a recurrence of the problems associated with the 2023 elections.
Nigerians are entitled to know what has changed, what is being improved and what guarantees exist that the mistakes of the past will not be repeated.
THE GUILTY ARE AFRAID
There is an old expression that the guilty are afraid. It is a powerful expression, but it must be applied with caution. Fear, silence or a decision to remain inside a vehicle does not, by itself, establish guilt.
Nevertheless, public officials must appreciate the symbolism of their actions.
When the Chairman of an electoral commission refuses to engage citizens who are questioning the credibility of the electoral process, he risks reinforcing the very suspicions he ought to be addressing.
If he had come out, calmly listened to the protesters and explained INEC’s preparations for 2027, he might have turned an embarrassing confrontation into an opportunity to demonstrate confidence and leadership.
He could have said: We have heard your concerns. We are committed to free, fair and credible elections. We have nothing to hide. Judge us by our actions and the integrity of the process we deliver.
Even if the protesters remained unconvinced, he would have demonstrated that the electoral umpire was not afraid of public scrutiny.
That opportunity was lost.
However, the more important issue is not whether Professor Amupitan was afraid in London. It is whether Nigerians should be afraid of the electoral process that INEC is preparing to deliver in 2027.
That is the real question.
The Chairman has a responsibility to dispel these fears, not through public relations statements or carefully scripted speeches, but through verifiable actions that demonstrate institutional independence.
He must understand that the credibility of an election is not established on election day. It begins with the registration of voters, the recruitment and training of electoral personnel, the management of political parties, the deployment of technology and the transparent administration of every stage of the process.
The APC cap incident, if confirmed, must not be dismissed as a minor matter. The London confrontation must not be treated as an isolated embarrassment. Together, they point to a larger problem that demands institutional attention.
INEC must rise above partisan suspicion. Its officials must understand that they serve Nigeria, not the political interests of any administration.
Professor Amupitan must also understand that the office he occupies is bigger than his personality, his personal comfort and his political relationships.
He has an opportunity to restore public confidence in an institution that has suffered considerable reputational damage.
He must not waste it.
The 2027 elections cannot be another exercise in democratic disappointment. Nigerians deserve an electoral commission that is independent in character, impartial in conduct and transparent in operation.
The Chairman does not have to convince his critics that he is a good man. He has to convince Nigerians that the institution he heads is capable of conducting an election in which every vote counts and every political party has a fair opportunity.
And if he cannot answer questions about his preparedness, independence and neutrality, Nigerians have every right to keep asking.
After all, democracy does not belong to INEC. It belongs to the Nigerian people.
The real test of Professor Amupitan’s leadership is not whether he can escape an angry crowd in London. It is whether he can deliver an election in Nigeria whose outcome even his fiercest critics will find difficult to question.
Nze David N. Ugwu is the Managing Consultant of Knowledge Research Consult. He could be reached at [email protected] or +2348037269333.
