Has Tinubu Turned Nigeria Into A Cappuccino Economy?
When the economy looks attractive from the top but leaves millions struggling at the bottom
By
Nze David N. Ugwu
There is something deeply symbolic about the cappuccino. It is a drink made up of espresso, steamed milk and a layer of foam. The coffee sits at the bottom, the milk occupies the middle, while the foam rises to the top. Each component has its place, but the appearance of the drink can sometimes be more impressive than its actual substance. In a cappuccino economy, the foam becomes the most visible part of the economic experience, while the substance beneath it remains inaccessible to the majority.
This metaphor raises an uncomfortable question about Nigeria under President Bola Ahmed Tinubu. Has the country become an economy in which the government celebrates rising revenues, improved macroeconomic indicators, expanding financial markets and impressive corporate profits, while ordinary Nigerians struggle to afford food, transportation, housing, education and healthcare? Is Nigeria experiencing genuine economic transformation, or is it merely producing the appearance of prosperity for a privileged minority?
The question is not whether Nigeria’s economy has changed since Tinubu assumed office in May 2023. It unquestionably has. The removal of the petrol subsidy, the reform of the foreign exchange market and the subsequent adjustments in government revenue have fundamentally altered the country’s economic landscape. The question is whether those changes have translated into a better life for the average Nigerian.
A cappuccino economy is not necessarily an economy without growth. It is an economy in which growth exists but its benefits are unevenly distributed. It is an economy in which the government may celebrate improved revenue, investors may celebrate profits, banks may report impressive earnings, and the political class may enjoy greater financial resources, while workers, pensioners, small businesses and struggling households continue to experience economic distress.
Nigeria must therefore be examined beyond the impressive headlines. The real test of economic policy is not what happens to government accounts or the balance sheets of powerful corporations. It is what happens to the lives of ordinary citizens.
The cappuccino metaphor may be provocative, but it captures a central contradiction in Nigeria’s present economic experience.
Tinubu inherited an economy burdened by subsidy payments, exchange-rate distortions, public debt, weak infrastructure, unemployment and longstanding structural problems. His administration argued that difficult reforms were necessary to prevent economic collapse and create a foundation for sustainable growth. There is considerable merit in the argument that Nigeria could not continue indefinitely with an expensive and poorly managed subsidy regime or multiple exchange-rate arrangements that encouraged arbitrage and corruption.
However, the existence of a legitimate economic problem does not automatically make every solution effective, equitable or properly implemented.
The removal of petrol subsidy was presented as a necessary fiscal intervention. It freed government resources that could be redirected toward infrastructure, social investment and development. Yet the immediate consequences for Nigerians were severe. Transportation costs increased, food prices rose, businesses faced higher operating expenses, and households experienced a dramatic reduction in purchasing power.
The government effectively transferred a substantial part of the economic adjustment to citizens before adequate protective measures were in place.
The problem was not simply that Nigerians were asked to endure temporary hardship. It was that the promised relief did not arrive with the speed, scale and credibility necessary to justify the sacrifices demanded of them.
A government may argue that reform is necessary, but citizens are entitled to ask: reform for whose benefit, and at what cost?
The exchange-rate reform presents a similar contradiction. Harmonizing the foreign exchange market was intended to reduce distortions, improve transparency and eliminate opportunities for privileged access to cheap foreign currency. These were reasonable objectives.
But the sharp depreciation of the naira also increased the cost of imported goods, machinery, raw materials, medicines and production inputs. Since Nigeria remains heavily dependent on imports, the consequences extended far beyond the foreign exchange market.
Manufacturers faced rising costs. Traders struggled to replenish inventories. Businesses that depended on imported materials experienced financial pressure. Consumers found themselves paying more for goods whose prices were increasingly disconnected from their incomes.
The government could point to the elimination of certain distortions, but the ordinary citizen experienced the reform principally through the cost of living.
This is where the cappuccino economy becomes relevant. The government sees the economic restructuring. Investors see opportunities. Financial institutions see improved earnings. But the household sees the price of rice, the cost of transportation, school fees and the amount remaining after essential expenses have been paid.
The same economy produces different realities depending on where one stands.
And the distance between those realities is becoming a major political and economic concern.
The most troubling feature of this economic experience is the growing perception that the benefits of reform are concentrated among those who already possess economic power.
Government revenue has increased substantially following the reforms. Federal, state and local governments have received higher allocations from the Federation Account. In principle, this should create opportunities for improved infrastructure, better public services, employment generation and poverty reduction.
Yet increased government revenue does not automatically translate into improved living conditions.
The critical question is what the political class has done with the additional resources.
A June 2025 analysis published by The Punch argued that the benefits of Nigeria’s economic policies had favored the political class, large businesses and financial institutions, while the conditions of ordinary citizens remained difficult. The analysis also questioned whether increased allocations to state governments were producing meaningful improvements in citizens’ welfare.
This is an important distinction between economic growth and economic development.
Growth measures the expansion of economic activity. Development measures whether that expansion improves human welfare.
An economy can grow without significantly reducing poverty. Government revenue can increase without improving public education. Banks can report higher profits without creating enough productive employment. The stock market can perform impressively while millions of households struggle to meet their basic needs.
The cappuccino economy emerges when these contradictions become normalised.
The foam becomes the headline. The substance becomes the struggle.
Nigeria’s middle class is particularly vulnerable to this economic arrangement.
The middle class is the foundation of a stable and productive economy. It provides skilled labour, supports consumer demand, pays taxes, invests in education and contributes to the development of small businesses. It is also an important source of social stability because its members generally possess the economic security necessary to plan for the future.
However, when inflation rises faster than incomes, the middle class begins to lose its economic position.
Professionals who previously maintained comfortable households find themselves making difficult choices. Parents withdraw children from expensive schools. Families postpone medical treatment. Workers reduce transportation expenses. Savings lose value. Retirement plans become uncertain.
The middle class does not necessarily disappear overnight. It gradually descends into economic insecurity.
This development has serious implications for Nigeria’s future.
A shrinking middle class means reduced purchasing power, weaker domestic demand and fewer opportunities for businesses to expand. It also means that more citizens become dependent on government assistance, informal economic activities or the financial support of relatives.
An economy cannot build sustainable prosperity by continuously pushing its productive middle class toward poverty.
The problem becomes even more serious when small and medium-sized enterprises are considered.
Small businesses are among the most important sources of employment in Nigeria. They provide livelihoods for millions of people, support local production and contribute to economic diversification.
Yet these businesses are particularly vulnerable to inflation, high interest rates, electricity costs, transportation expenses and exchange-rate instability.
A large company may possess sufficient financial resources to absorb temporary economic shocks. A small business operating with limited capital may not survive them.
When a bakery faces rising flour prices, increased electricity expenses and higher transportation costs, it must either increase prices, reduce production or close down.
When a manufacturer cannot afford imported machinery or replacement parts, production becomes more expensive.
When a retailer cannot replenish stock because the cost of goods has increased beyond the purchasing power of customers, business activity declines.
These are not merely business problems. They are employment problems.
Every business that closes represents lost income, reduced opportunities and additional pressure on households.
The government cannot claim that economic reforms are succeeding simply because some large corporations are performing well.
The real question is whether the economy is creating opportunities for businesses of different sizes to survive, expand and employ Nigerians.
A cappuccino economy may produce a few impressive corporate champions while leaving thousands of smaller enterprises struggling beneath the surface.
That is not sustainable economic transformation.
It is economic concentration.
Another disturbing dimension is the relationship between political power and economic privilege.
Nigeria’s political environment has increasingly raised questions about whether access to government remains one of the most reliable routes to wealth accumulation.
When political officeholders enjoy substantial financial advantages while public services remain inadequate, citizens naturally begin to question the fairness of the economic system.
When politicians move between parties without clear ideological differences, but with considerable attention to political advantage, the public may conclude that political competition is primarily about access to resources.
When government allocations increase but citizens cannot identify corresponding improvements in healthcare, education, infrastructure and employment, public confidence weakens.
This is particularly dangerous because economic reforms require political trust.
Citizens are more likely to tolerate temporary hardship when they believe the sacrifices are fairly distributed and that the benefits will eventually reach them.
They become less willing to endure hardship when they perceive that the political class is insulated from the consequences of its own policies.
Economic reform without political accountability can therefore become a source of social instability.
The cappuccino economy is not merely about unequal income distribution. It is also about unequal exposure to economic hardship.
Those with access to foreign currency, substantial investments, political influence and diversified income sources are better positioned to protect themselves against inflation.
Those who depend entirely on monthly salaries, pensions or small business earnings have fewer options.
The same increase in food prices that represents an inconvenience for a wealthy household may become a serious threat to survival for a low-income family.
The same increase in transportation costs that reduces the disposable income of a senior executive may prevent a low-paid worker from attending work regularly.
Economic hardship is therefore not experienced equally.
This is why government economic assessments must go beyond aggregate indicators.
Inflation declining from an extremely high level does not mean prices have returned to affordable levels. A slower rate of price increases does not reverse the cumulative damage already experienced by households.
If the price of a commodity rises dramatically and subsequently increases more slowly, consumers are still paying the higher price.
The difference between disinflation and falling prices must be understood in public economic communication.
Similarly, exchange-rate stability does not necessarily mean that the naira has recovered its purchasing power.
A currency can become relatively stable after experiencing substantial depreciation. Stability at a significantly weaker level may improve predictability without restoring the purchasing power previously lost.
The government must therefore avoid presenting improvements in the rate of deterioration as equivalent to improvements in citizens’ welfare.
The ultimate question is whether Nigerians can afford the economy they are being asked to support.
Can a civil servant comfortably feed a family, pay school fees, maintain a home and save for retirement?
Can a young graduate find meaningful employment without depending on political connections?
Can a small business borrow money at a reasonable cost and expand production?
Can a pensioner maintain a decent standard of living without relying on relatives?
Can an ordinary Nigerian access healthcare without risking financial ruin?
These are the questions that determine whether economic reform is delivering development.
The cappuccino economy also raises a fundamental issue about the government’s priorities.
Economic reform should not be limited to correcting fiscal and monetary distortions. It must also create the conditions necessary for productive activity.
Nigeria needs an economy in which agriculture becomes more productive, manufacturing becomes competitive, infrastructure supports business expansion, and public institutions provide reliable services.
The country needs policies that encourage investment in domestic production rather than excessive dependence on imported goods.
It needs a transportation system that reduces the cost of moving people and goods.
It needs electricity that allows businesses to operate without spending an unreasonable proportion of their resources on alternative power.
It needs a tax system that generates revenue without suffocating struggling businesses.
Above all, it needs a government that understands that economic policy is ultimately about people.
The solution is not necessarily to reverse every reform introduced by Tinubu’s administration.
Returning to an inefficient subsidy regime or recreating multiple exchange-rate arrangements could reproduce the problems that originally necessitated reform.
The challenge is to correct the deficiencies in implementation and ensure that economic adjustment is accompanied by meaningful social protection.
Government should prioritize targeted assistance for vulnerable households, support productive employment, improve public transportation and ensure that increased revenue produces visible public benefits.
State governments must demonstrate how their additional allocations are improving citizens’ lives.
Public expenditure should be more transparent, and political officeholders should be held accountable for the resources entrusted to them.
The government must also strengthen the productive economy by reducing the cost of doing business, improving access to finance and supporting sectors capable of generating large-scale employment.
Economic growth should be measured not only by the size of the national economy but also by the number of Nigerians whose economic circumstances are improving.
The success of Tinubu’s economic reforms will ultimately depend on whether they produce a more inclusive economy.
A country cannot sustain prosperity when a significant proportion of its population is excluded from its benefits.
Nor can economic stability be guaranteed when citizens increasingly perceive the economic system as unfair.
Nigeria must move beyond the celebration of macroeconomic indicators and confront the realities of household economics.
The government must recognize that the economy does not exist merely to balance accounts, improve statistics or generate impressive corporate earnings.
It exists to improve the lives of citizens.
The cappuccino metaphor is therefore a warning.
An economy may look attractive from the top while remaining bitter at the bottom.
It may produce impressive headlines while households experience declining purchasing power.
It may generate higher government revenue while public services remain inadequate.
It may create wealth for a privileged minority while millions struggle to survive.
The question is whether Nigeria will continue to tolerate this contradiction or begin building an economy in which prosperity is more widely shared.
Tinubu’s economic reforms may eventually produce significant benefits. But those benefits must be visible in employment, affordable food, accessible healthcare, improved education, productive businesses and greater household security.
The administration cannot indefinitely ask Nigerians to judge economic performance by the promise of future prosperity.
At some point, the promise must become reality.
The ultimate test of Tinubu’s economic policy is not whether Nigeria has become a cappuccino economy. It is whether the government can transform the present economic experience from one of concentrated prosperity and widespread hardship into one of shared opportunity and sustainable development.
Until ordinary Nigerians begin to feel the benefits of economic reform in their daily lives, the question will remain:
Has Tinubu transformed Nigeria’s economy, or has he merely improved the appearance of prosperity while leaving millions struggling beneath the foam?
And perhaps the most important question of all is this:
What is the value of an economy that looks impressive in government reports but remains unaffordable to the people it is supposed to serve?
Â
 Nze David N. Ugwu is the Managing Consultant of Knowledge Research Consult. He could be reached at [email protected] or +2348037269333.
